Cricket’s modern day dilemma: Is fitness or talent worth more?

Cricket’s modern day dilemma: Is fitness or talent worth more?

Once upon a time, cricket was seen as a common sport. Not simply in its attraction to a worldwide viewers however for the truth that people of any form, measurement, color, creed or class may play alongside one another.

With the news that Dane van Niekerk, among the finest gamers within the ladies’s sport, has been neglected of South Africa’s Twenty20 World Cup squad on health grounds alone, this age-old notion may have landed within the trash can.

Less athletic gamers, it appears, are actually being penalised, irrespective of how good they’re at really enjoying cricket. And but a number of the biggest gamers would have struggled to move health assessments, definitely of their older years.

WG Grace, who used to “block shooters to the boundary” within the nineteenth century, might have began his profession as a lithe athlete however had little time for the sharp single as his waistline expanded in his thirties and forties.

Warwick Armstrong, considered one of Australia’s biggest captains within the early a part of the twentieth century, was often known as the “Big Ship” due to his 130kg body and billowing shirt.

Van Niekerk, 29, is a leg-spinning all-rounder and the one South African girl to have scored greater than 1,500 runs and brought greater than 50 wickets in ladies’s T20 internationals.

From 2016 to 2021 she captained the facet in all three codecs. However, she final performed for the nationwide staff in September 2021 and has been recovering from a damaged ankle.

Her exclusion from the World Cup squad was as a result of she didn’t obtain the required time for a two-kilometre run.

Having misplaced 10kg since enjoying in England final summer season and regardless of operating a private finest, she missed the 9 minute 30 seconds restrict by 18 seconds which, in response to staff officers, was not adequate.

“Dane was given an extensive opportunity to meet the minimum criteria, or the fitness benchmark for eligibility into the World Cup,” mentioned ladies’s choice convener Clinton du Preez.

“It’s purely based on the not meeting of the fitness criteria that she’s missed out.”

Van Niekerk mentioned she was “broken” by the choice to exclude her from the World Cup which begins on her residence patch on February 10, however the choice might backfire on the South Africans who now go into the match with out two, possibly even three, of their finest gamers.

Last 12 months, one other key participant Lizelle Lee was neglected of the tour to England and Ireland for failing to satisfy her weight requirement. She subsequently retired from worldwide cricket so as to play within the franchises.

And, though she was named within the World Cup squad, there should be some doubt as as to if Marizanne Kapp will stroll away in protest. She is married to Van Niekerk and pulled out of Thursday’s T20 towards India for “personal” causes.

South Africa is just not the one nation to have health assessments however they do seem one of many extra inflexible.

Sisanda Magala, who performed within the latest males’s ODI sequence towards England, was excluded from the squad final 12 months after equally failing to satisfy the goal, in his case by 12 seconds.

The Van Niekerk choice highlights, nevertheless, a pattern in cricket which is seeing a squeeze on athletes who’re constructed extra for consolation than pace.

The rise of short-form cricket is definitely an element because the fielding abilities are actually far superior of what they have been even 10 years in the past.

The pure energy benefit that larger gamers resembling Colin Milburn or the “short and stocky” New Zealand wicketkeeper Jock Edwards might have had previously is much less very important now that bats have change into sledgehammer and limits have been shortened.

What future then for the likes of West Indies off-spinner Rahkeem Cornwall, listed on his Wiki web page as weighing in at 140 kilos, or the Pakistani batsman Azam Khan who continues to be mocked, as seen on Twitter this week as he walked out to bat within the Bangladesh Premier League, even after dropping 30 kilos?

“It’s not about being overweight, it’s about performance,” mentioned Azam, making the case for the defence in an article in January’s Cricket Monthly.

“If a guy is scoring 400 runs and he is super-fit and another guy is scoring 800 runs and he is not super-fit, I will keep the guy who scored 800 runs in my team. That’s my point of view.”

Originally revealed as Cricket news: Dane van Niekerk to overlook T20 World Cup resulting from health, what does this imply for cricket?

Source: www.news.com.au