You can scent it within the air; footy is nearly right here.
And simply days out from the season opener two skilled panels – Jonathan Brown, Jordan Lewis and Mark Robinson, after which David King, Leigh Montagna and Brad Johnson – have met to debate the approaching AFL marketing campaign.
Watch each match of each spherical of the 2023 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE on Kayo Sports. New to Kayo? Start your free trial now >
ADELAIDE CROWS
LAST YEAR: 14th, 8-14, 89.8%
Jordan Lewis: They are a tough crew to try to assess. I feel they’ll enhance on the eight wins final 12 months.
What I liked on the backend of final 12 months is Darcy Fogarty. I feel he will be among the finest key forwards within the competitors. He kicked 31 objectives within the backend of final 12 months. He appears highly effective.
They haven’t settled on a second key ahead, it most likely settles all the way down to (Elliott) Himmelberg and (Riley) Thilthorpe. I feel (Taylor) Walker at the beginning of the season will get the No.1 defender, then Fogarty will get the No.2 and I feel he’ll dominate.
Jonathan Brown: Rankine is an efficient pickup, 29 objectives at Gold Coast final 12 months. (Shane) McAdam, (Josh) Rachele, Ben Keays kicked 4 on the weekend as a mid-forward.
They’ve received some choices, they’re hardworking, I feel their midfield is fairly hard-nosed as effectively. Matty Nicks has them taking part in the appropriate means.
They’ve received some good intercepting defenders in Dawson and Doedee. All components of their sport are shaping up properly. They’re constructing, I count on them to maintain enhancing.
Mark Robinson: If you barrack for Adelaide, you need your crew to exit and have a go. Forget the methods … each time the ball is close to you, you battle prefer it’s the final ball on Earth.
When you watch the Crows play, it’s a tick. Matthew Nicks has executed a extremely good job at establishing that Hawthorn animal (feeling), they’re a troublesome crew.
Lewis: It’s necessary how they combine him (Rankine). When he’s taking part in his finest soccer it’s comparatively easy soccer – you see some components of his sport which can be good. So it’s essential say we’ve received you for a selected motive, we don’t want you to be a game-winner, simply are available in and play a task. Other stuff will occur when issues open up, however we don’t have to see this flashy stuff, however we wish to see the tackling, the arduous in-and-under stuff.
I mentioned backside 4 nevertheless it wouldn’t shock me – I did it (the prediction) a few days in the past – it wouldn’t shock me now in the event that they had been 8 to 10.
Predicted end
Brown: 9-12
Lewis: Bottom 4 (Upgraded to 8-10)
Robinson: 8-12
BRISBANE LIONS
LAST YEAR: sixth and misplaced preliminary closing, 15-7, 119.3%
Brown: I went as much as watch the boys prepare pre-Christmas, I used to be actually impressed by the midfield. The huge improve is within the midfield.
For me they’ve been bullied, they haven’t been capable of go together with the massive boys when the whips are cracking. I look on the market at coaching, I see (Josh) Dunkley controlling the sector, I see a Lachie Neale who’s tremendous match and I’ve seen (Will) Ashcroft, he appears like he’s performed 200 video games already, he’s on the market commanding, giving orders. Their midfield has upgraded.
(Jack) Gunston’s inclusion goes to be superb, it modifications the steadiness of their ahead line. I’m truly optimistic once I will be crucial, I get annoyed with the Lions nevertheless it’s simply because I’ve received the eagerness for them. I’ve received them high two.
Robinson: This 12 months they’ll ask (Brandon) Starcevich to play taller … I feel (Keidean) Coleman could possibly be All Australian.
It’s going to come back all the way down to moments, they’ve failed on the second-last hurdle and once they fail they fail badly. They’ll end second for me.
Lewis: I feel bodily and when it comes to their expertise they’re as effectively positioned as any aspect within the competitors. It’s how they deal with the again finish of the season mentally and bodily. Do they’ve it in-between the ears and have they got the power to play exterior themselves bodily when the sport will get actually arduous?
I’ve received them high 4. They want that second likelihood, in the event that they must go away week one (it’s an issue).
Predicted end
Brown: Top 2
Lewis: Top 4
Robinson: Top 2
CARLTON
LAST YEAR: ninth, 12-10, 108.3%
Brown: Certainly there’ll be some learnings popping out of these previous couple of weeks once they misplaced these shut video games, so he’ll (Michael Voss) be capable of put them into some match-type eventualities.
But I feel they’re constructing, there’s a few harm issues early – Sam Walsh, Zac Williams – however they’ve received not a nasty draw early. The first two are Richmond and Geelong however then can they settle themselves, the subsequent month they play sides exterior the highest eight. They’re very reliant on their midfield and their forwards for the time being so once they win clearance, they seem like a extremely harmful aspect.
What about behind the soccer? They’ve received Jacob Weitering who’s a star, they’ve received some actually good operating again flankers, who’s the second defender there? Is it (Lewis) Young, is it (Lachie) Plowman? What about Mitch McGovern, is he a very powerful participant on Carlton’s listing?
Robinson: It’s not a silly query as a result of if he can play and maintain down that secondary key again, it helps them as a result of they’re a bit skinny on the bottom there.
Lewis: He’s not solely necessary for that defensive stability however he has the power to kick the ball throughout the bottom shortly, so if you consider switching the play, should you’re a midfielder and you don’t have anybody within the again half who can do this, you are typically a bit sluggish and gravitate to at least one aspect, and search for the smaller ones.
If I’m trying down now and I’m a Carlton midfielder, and McGovern’s received the ball, you wish to get in your bike and open the sport up somewhat bit extra.
I mentioned high eight, it wouldn’t shock me in the event that they’re high 4. Their backbone is precisely what it’s essential be a finals contender year-on-year and so they’ve received a litany of stars round that as effectively. They would’ve realized some classes within the again finish of final 12 months.
Predicted end
Brown: Bottom of high 8
Lewis: Top 8
Robinson: 8-12
COLLINGWOOD
LAST YEAR: 4th and misplaced preliminary closing, 16-6, 104.3%
Brown: I like the very fact they’ve upgraded their listing. Clearly they suppose the time is now, so (Tom) Mitchell, Bobby Hill, (Billy) Frampton and (Dan) McStay, and you might argue all 4 of these will play in Round 1. So they’ve robotically upgraded the listing.
The query mark is that ahead group … and we noticed it within the again finish of final 12 months, can (Darcy) Cameron and Mason Cox maintain up within the ruck? Let’s keep in mind (Brodie) Grundy, together with Max Gawn, has been essentially the most dominant ruckman within the final decade or so. All of a sudden we’re going oh no, that’s OK, Grundy’s gone. How a lot does that impact them?
I feel (Jordan) De Goey is primed for an enormous 12 months. He will be All-Australian this 12 months … the way in which he performed towards Hawthorn final week and predominantly out of the centre was sensational.
Robinson: This man, he now is aware of he can personal the a part of the bottom. And that takes time with gamers. He’s a expertise, however now it’s ‘hang on, I can do a lot’. He was prowling the centre sq. – he regarded like Dusty.
They’re OK ahead. They’re OK again. I don’t suppose Frampton’s a lock for key defence, after which they’re deep within the midfield … they’ve received great religion in Cameron.
Lewis: I might query their defence. At levels final 12 months once they had been remoted, they’re not nice one-on-one gamers, they do depend on delay up the bottom to allow them to zone off in Jeremy Howe and Darcy Moore. If they’re actually remoted, and also you get a aspect like a Bulldogs on the weekend once they go 4 real talls, how will a aspect like Collingwood match up towards that?
And you discuss their listing final 12 months, they had been actually wholesome when it comes to accidents.
I’ve them simply exterior the highest eight nevertheless it wouldn’t shock me in the event that they completed seventh or eighth. I simply suppose final 12 months was an excellent 12 months for them. Don’t get me unsuitable, they had been superb, however there was part of it that you just’re simply rolling in movement due to the fanfare.
Now sides will hunt them down -it’s so arduous through the 12 months to do a extremely deep dissection of a crew, and seeing Collingwood the way in which they progressed final 12 months, little question sides would have most likely dissected them extra so than every other aspect within the competitors.
Predicted end
Brown: Bottom of high 8
Lewis: Just exterior high 8
Robinson: Top 4
ESSENDON
LAST YEAR: fifteenth, 7-15, 83.2%
Robinson: I spoke about it on the primary 360 of the 12 months, I’m actually stunned the senior folks on the membership had been saying ‘we’re solely younger, we’re solely younger, simply wait’. Essendon supporters have been listening to that for 15 years.
I’d quite hear them say guess what? We’re gonna hit this 12 months with all the things we’ve received, and if we come up quick, we’ll fill the holes over a few years.
Essendon have gotten (Dylan) Shiel. (Zach) Merrett. (Dyson) Heppell. (Jordan) Ridley. (Jayden) Laverde. (Darcy) Parish is not younger. Jake Stringer.
Lewis: They’re the Sixteenth-oldest listing within the AFL; solely two groups are youthful. Collingwood are fifth … so you possibly can perceive a coach coming in and understanding what he’s received when it comes to the taking part in group.
This is a membership that hasn’t had a growth system. So you have a look at the important thing gamers for Essendon in the event that they ultimately develop into premiers – (Nik) Cox, (Sam) Draper will likely be concerned, (Harry) Jones, (Nic) Martin’s only a younger participant, (Archie) Perkins.
Cox (has performed) 27 video games, Draper 43, Jones 26, Martin 21, Perkins 30, (Zach) Reid eight video games.
(Being a part of the teaching search) you get an perception into what they’ve executed beforehand, what the previous teaching regime may’ve targeted on and what the brand new one might doubtlessly be, however you additionally get a way of this system and the place their vitality has been targeted, and it hasn’t been in growth.
I feel they could scrape into the eight and I do know that’s a daring prediction. But I simply suppose with the expertise they’ve received and the coaches which have are available in, and type of reshaped them. I feel they could scrape into the eight, which’d be a shock I do know that, nevertheless it wouldn’t be past them.
Brown: The final couple of years I’ve usually checked out Essendon and thought they appear a bit gentle. So I go searching their group – who’re their leaders, who’re their ruthless gamers?
Yes they’re younger, I feel they’ve received some good younger expertise there, however I wish to see extra than simply these outside-type gamers. I wish to see some gamers begin to rise up and stand for one thing at that nice soccer membership.
Predicted end
Brown: Bottom 3
Lewis: Just exterior high 8
Robinson: Bottom 4
FREMANTLE
LAST YEAR: fifth and misplaced semi closing, 15-1-6, 117%
Lewis: Where do they get their scoring from? They lose (Rory) Lobb, he was their main goalscorer final 12 months, and the subsequent three are all smalls.
The largest factor for me is how they use (Nat) Fyfe and (Luke) Jackson to then be capable of kick a rating to compete. We know they’ll limit sides, they’ve proven that year-on-year.
Brown: I feel Jackson is an honest ahead, I assumed at occasions he confirmed he’s a wonderful athlete, however he not solely appears like he can take a mark, he appears like he can discover some ground-level ball.
I don’t thoughts Jackson simply launching himself on the ball as the primary a part of his craft, as a result of that’s going to trigger some spills. I feel Fyfe is the opposite one as effectively, he appears primed for a giant 12 months.
He’ll be used primarily as a ahead. I feel he could possibly be an All-Australian ahead … we all know he was a reluctant ahead, I feel he understands now he wants to have the ability to settle for this function if he needs to be a part of a premiership crew.
Don’t underestimate the street journey – hardest in soccer.
Robinson: I’ve not received the religion his (Fyfe’s) physique will rise up – and I don’t suppose he’s an excellent ahead, he’s among the finest gamers we’ve ever seen, however I don’t suppose he’s an excellent ahead. I wouldn’t have him deep ahead as a result of he’s not an excellent kick! He’s going be a extremely intriguing watch.
Predicted end
Brown: 5-8
Lewis: Bottom of high 8
Robinson: 6-7
GEELONG CATS
LAST YEAR: 1st and premiers, 18-4, 144.2%
Robinson: The very first thing you’ve received to take a look at with a crew that’s gained the premiership is the starvation stage. Do they wish to climb the mountain once more? You will be hungry, however are you canine hungry?
Geelong had a method final 12 months – Collingwood almost beat them – however that opposition groups couldn’t crack. They’ve received a system that’s the finest within the competitors as we communicate. The soccer division, led by Chris Scott, modified the way in which they performed. I feel they’ll go back-to-back.
Brown: Chris Scott is without doubt one of the smartest coaches within the AFL. You know what he does higher than every other coach within the competitors? He will get the very best out of his finest gamers. He exploits their strengths.
Look at (Mark) Blicavs, (Tom) Stewart, giving (Jeremy) Cameron a license … you want your finest gamers taking part in finest on the most important stage and Chris Scott doesn’t sit on his palms.
Lewis: The largest problem with a aspect that has been up and about is the primary half of the season. You know you’ll be there within the backend, that’s going to occur. How are you able to financial institution sufficient wins within the early a part of the season, couple that being with out one of many biggest participant/captains that we’ve ever seen, you’ve received that emotional void that it’s a must to fill.
Patrick Dangerfield doesn’t must be Joel Selwood, he’s going to guide in his personal means. There is a few change throughout the soccer membership, however they’ve received an abundance of expertise that you just suppose would be capable of cope.
It’s little issues like gamers coming in and doing their monitoring. Are they turning as much as massages on time? All these little issues behind the scenes mount and present indicators of complacency.
Predicted end
Brown: Top 4
Lewis: Top 4
Robinson: Premiers
GOLD COAST SUNS
LAST YEAR: twelfth, 10-12, 102.8%
Brown: I spent a couple of weeks there over summer season, bumped into a couple of folks in and across the organisation. The comparable message I stored listening to was, we’ve received to make finals this 12 months.
I ponder whether there’s some inner strain – is that coming from the AFL? I feel now could be the time. They had been over 100 per cent final 12 months, they gained 10 video games final 12 months, it was their finest 12 months. Is it finals or bust?
Robinson: If they go terribly dangerous, he’s (Stuart Dew) in hassle, however I don’t suppose they’re gonna go terribly dangerous. I feel they’re going to be difficult for the eight and so they’re gonna beat a variety of groups.
The solely concern for me – that younger midfield, Miller, Witts who’s a bit older, Rowell, Anderson, Swallow’s an older participant. Can your Davies, Berry, Fiorini, Hollands, Flanders, these next-level gamers, can they push by way of? Some of them will.
But we have a look at their two most necessary gamers for the time being – Ben King coming again, 47 objectives in 2021, did his knee final 12 months, and clearly Touk Miller. Touk Miller’s a star.
Lewis: Their finest 22, should you measure Gold Coast this 12 months, I don’t suppose it’s essentially finals or not. It’s, do they get enchancment on final 12 months and stack up towards the actually good indicators within the competitors? And blow away the edges they need to, however how do they stack up towards a Brisbane, a Geelong, a Melbourne?
Ben King is the one for me – he modifies the place their future is.
Predicted end
Brown: 12-15
Lewis: Just exterior high 8
Robinson: Just exterior high 8
GWS GIANTS
LAST YEAR: Sixteenth, 6-16, 84.6%
Robinson: Looking on the Giants final 12 months, it was all falling aside. They misplaced Leon (Cameron), there was patchwork happening in every single place. And the gamers simply fall away – that’s what occurs.
They’ve received 4 gamers on one million {dollars} – (Stephen) Coniglio, (Josh) Kelly, (Toby) Greene and (Lachie) Whitfield … we noticed them as soon as within the pre-season and it was as Gerard Healy as soon as mentioned, the tsunami. They had been taking part in a distinct model of soccer, and all of a sudden the expertise of Kelly, Whitfield, it comes out once more.
I actually like Tom Green as a participant, I feel he’s going to take monumental advances this 12 months.
I don’t suppose they’ll problem for the eight – it’d be a terrific teaching efficiency from Adam Kinglsey to get them into the finals. But what we wish to see is a compete each week angle. And that’s what I’m feeling from Kingsley; he’s an old-schooler.
Lewis: I don’t suppose he (Kingsley) suffers fools. It’s getting ingrained that toughness and the basics and hey, I’ll allow you to play once you show to me you are able to do that. It feels to me it’s that sort of setup.
They must be a greater aspect than what they had been final 12 months. With the quantity of expertise, and then you definately don’t swap on the TV to look at GWS, that exhibits how boring they had been.
Brown: I like the selection of Toby Greene as a solo captain. He is perhaps again to the highest two or three gamers on the finish of the 12 months.
Robinson: Harry Himmelberg final 12 months was an actual shining gentle final 12 months at fullback. He’s been taking part in again ahead.
You’ve received Sam Taylor who’s among the finest key defenders within the comp. That group, Isaac Cumming, they’re underrated. That was one group final 12 months that was most likely holding them in affordable stead. So they’ve received a extremely good foundation again there.
Predicted end
Brown: 12-15
Lewis: Just exterior high 8
Robinson: 12-15
HAWTHORN
LAST YEAR: thirteenth, 8-14, 89.8%
Brad Johnson: My view goes to James Sicily as skipper. He’s received to remain on the park for 22 weeks, sure he’s received to be aggressive in his contests, and he’s received to set a typical defensively as effectively.
But who else can he convey into his little bubble in management to assist develop the crew? Especially when his place down again, who’s he getting to manage the midfield, who’s he getting to manage the ahead line when he’s received different duties to carry out?
In the midfield it’s (Jai) Newcombe, I do know he’s younger however he’s the primary man in that place.
Leigh Montagna: They’ve nonetheless received an extended method to go … they’re actually in it for the lengthy haul. Just hold getting video games into youngsters, kind out which of them are the long run, which of them possibly aren’t fairly as much as it.
Got to be affected person as a supporter with the Hawks. Sam Mitchell will try to construct a gameplan that’s going to stack as much as win finals – for the time being it’s fairly offensive and so they’re getting a variety of run off halfback.
David King: We’re fairly fast to say they’re younger and so they can’t obtain. When you have a look at the Super Macs, Cam Mackenzie and (Connor) Macdonald, they’re going to take management of this midfield fairly fast.
We spoke about Newcombe – I’m unsure if he’s an All-Australian stage participant or strong B-grader, however he’s going to win a variety of finest and fairests on this group. His scope will dictate how shortly it comes.
(Changkuoth) Jiath throughout halfback mixed with Sicily, (Sam) Frost, (Jarman) Impey, (Blake) Hardwick, I feel their again six is actually strong and so they can counterpunch from there. They’re gonna win a few video games this 12 months that you just don’t count on them to win on the again of fine teaching.
I’m simply fearful they’ve gone thus far backwards that the coach (has to) get the total run of the subsequent two, three, 4, 5 years to see this by way of, however I can see the items constructing.
Predicted end
Johnson: Bottom 4
King: Bottom 4
Montagna: Bottom 4
MELBOURNE
LAST YEAR: 2nd and misplaced semi closing, 16-6, 130.5%
Montagna: We know the cracks began to seem halfway by way of final 12 months, and a variety of it needed to do with their predictability with their ball motion. Teams labored them out, they had been a bit too secure, notably popping out of defence and going inside 50.
The remainder of their sport nonetheless held up fairly effectively, nonetheless a terrific midfield contest crew, their defence led by (Steven) May and (Jake) Lever we all know is elite. The solely factor they should work on is their ball motion; they had been 18th going by way of the hall final season.
From what we’ve seen throughout the pre-season they’ve addressed that; they’re going to take the sport on extra, they’re now attacking the highest of the sq. as a substitute of going into the pocket. For me that was their solely situation, they’ve labored on that every one summer season and there’s no motive why the Dees can’t win it this 12 months.
Johnson: The solely small concern I do have is the important thing ahead side. Defensively they’ll maintain up, their midfield’s most likely the very best if not within the high two within the competitors.
It simply appears the sport goes in direction of the important thing forwards – so (Ben) Brown, (Tom) McDonald, I simply can’t see that mixture attending to 80 objectives for the 12 months. And once you have a look at what Geelong did final 12 months with Cameron and Hawkins, 132 (objectives), the place you see the place the competitors’s going together with your two keys up entrance, that’s the one situation I’ve with Melbourne’s push ahead.
Montagna: I’m not too involved – you are able to do it in numerous methods and their ball motion will dictate that. Remember Bayley Fritsch is a 50-plus goalkicker, Kozzie Pickett’s kicked 40 objectives the final two years, if (Christian) Petracca spends a bit extra time down there he can kick 20-30 objectives.
King: I feel they’ll expose some youthful expertise notably early within the 12 months, as a result of we’ve seen the identical block of 25 gamers for most likely three years in a row now.
You’ll see extra of Kade Chandler, Pickett on the finish of this season could possibly be the very best centre-forward participant within the competitors … Tom Sparrow’s somebody that may go subsequent stage along with his soccer, he’s been on the sting able to have that quantum leap.
I’m gonna tip them to be premiers however my solely reservation is that they’ve had a brutal pre-season from the second they’ve come again – are you able to maintain and preserve the fashion proper by way of the tip of September? I’ve received little question they’ll be high of the desk on the bye rounds, however that was the identical final 12 months.
Predicted end
Johnson: Top 4
King: Top 4 and premiers
Montagna: Top 4 and premiers
NORTH MELBOURNE
LAST YEAR: 18th, 2-20, 55.8%
King: I truly suppose he’s (Alastair Clarkson) received a bit to work with. This crew has flown blind for the final two to 3 years; they haven’t performed with any actual construction or system in any respect. So what you’ve seen is absolute naked minimal, it’s floor zero.
They get a system in place, they get perception, they get some schooling and the 24-and-unders embody guys like (Jy) Simpkin, (Harry) McKay, (Tom) Powell, (Will) Phillips, Luke Davies-Uniacke, I feel Jackson Archer will likely be an excellent participant, I’m an enormous fan of Paul Curtis.
These guys simply must be taught easy methods to play the sport and that’s what’s occurred; they are going to compete. I’m fairly bullish on the place they’re going to be in two to 3 years, this will likely be a stepping stone 12 months, however I wouldn’t be shocked in the event that they gained eight video games or extra.
Montagna: I can see the inexperienced shoots as effectively with this group – between the 21-to-25-year age bracket – I wish to see Clarko coach some resilience and perception and confidence with them, and to teach them a system that’s going to stack up in finals.
I just like the core group they’ve received, they actually want so as to add some extra expertise however there’s sufficient there to work with.
Johnson: I feel they’re two years away from that development (to eight wins). Yes that they had some growth final 12 months, I like Davies-Uniacke and the way in which he performs his soccer, he performs the appropriate means. I’m with you on Curtis, Kingy, he’s received some actual upside to his sport, similar with (Bailey) Scott I feel he’ll have a giant 12 months.
But total, like what they did within the apply sport towards the Bulldogs – they’ll compete at occasions towards the higher groups however they’ll have their quarters the place they get blown away by 5 or 6 objectives and that’ll simply damage them on the win-loss. They’ll bridge the hole after which be capable of transcend that within the years to come back.
Predicted end
Johnson: Bottom 4
King: Bottom 4
Montagna: Bottom 4
PORT ADELAIDE
LAST YEAR: eleventh, 10-12, 110.3%
King: I feel they’ve develop into the Dallas Cowboys – they simply don’t win the massive video games. They simply don’t win towards the very best groups within the competitors, 2-9 towards top-eight groups.
You can return to the prelims should you like and say ought to they’ve gained these? I get they’re arduous to win, however should you’re going to achieve success on this competitors you’ve received to beat like sorts.
They’ve been constructing for a very long time now, they’ve received I feel an excellent listing. They’ve chopped and adjusted how they’ve performed, nevertheless it’s on the coach for me. All roads come again to Ken Hinkley, and I do know he’s been underneath strain for years, however he has to ship with this listing.
Their first 5 weeks – that’s it (Brisbane residence, Collingwood away, Adelaide, Sydney away, Bulldogs). I feel issues are actually powerful for them early and you may get actually wobbly as a soccer membership. Ken’s received to make each put up a winner within the first 5 weeks or he gained’t be there, they’ll make a name early.
It’s on a knife’s edge this teaching place. Those first 4 weeks aren’t crucial – his teaching profession will depend on it. We heard the waffle that got here out of there final 12 months once they had been 0-3, 0-4, 0-5, it’s simply too far to come back again from.
Johnson: It looks as if they’re holding a variety of hope for (Jason) Horne-Francis. It’s thrilling they’ve received a No.1 choose into their soccer membership however I nonetheless suppose he’s possibly 2-4 years away from being the participant he’ll get to on this competitors.
Even within the first apply sport, watching him carefully, he’s nonetheless standing there on the haunches and fatigued in quarters. We all had been at that age, so it’s going to take time. Yes he’ll have his moments and he’ll burst out of the pack and we’ll all go wow, how good is that, however we gained’t see him persistently on the high stage for a couple of years to come back.
Montagna: I’m a bit extra bullish, I feel they’ll play finals. No doubt they blew it final 12 months however then they went 8-3, their defence was very sturdy, and it fell away late.
On high of (Junior) Rioli, Lachie Jones can enhance, and if (Orazio) Fantasia stays match, (Miles) Bergman appears like he’s going to be a magnificence on a wing, (Kane) Farrell’s going to fill a task and (Connor) Rozee and (Zak) Butters – there’s nonetheless a variety of room for enchancment with this aspect. I feel they nonetheless imagine in Ken and so they’ll purchase in. They ought to be anticipating to play finals.
Predicted end
Johnson: Just miss finals
King: Just miss finals
Montagna: Finals
RICHMOND
LAST YEAR: seventh and misplaced elimination closing, 13-1-8, 121.6%
Johnson: They’ll be sturdy, off the again of what they had been capable of get to final 12 months after which off the again of (Tim) Taranto and (Jacob) Hopper including into the midfield.
It provides a layer of energy immediately that I feel they want – although in saying that even Taranto and Hopper and a few the opposite mids from the primary apply sport, an actual eye-opener when it comes to working from the competition.
Melbourne destroyed them out at Casey. They’ll have a look at that and must do a variety of work mentally over the subsequent couple of weeks to get themselves set.
Montagna: It’s going to be fascinating how that ahead line works. Offensively it sounds fairly good however simply defensively I’ve received some slight questions; once you have a look at (Noah) Cumberland, (Trent) Cotchin, (Dustin) Martin, Shai Bolton when he’s down there and (Maurice) Rioli, their strain scores are all under common or common.
They’re not elite strain and once you consider Richmond’s premiership groups and that relentlessness within the entrance half, it was off the again of (Jason) Castagna, (Dan) Butler, (Daniel) Rioli when he used to play there, (Shane) Edwards, Jack Graham.
Last 12 months they struggled to cease the opposition shifting the ball from one finish of the sector to the opposite and their strain score was poor. Have they addressed that?
King: I feel Damien Hardwick has been working off two of the three sides of the sport; he’s by no means actually been capable of compete with the contested and clearance angle.
You get Hopper and Taranto in and swiftly, you possibly can beat opposition groups with all three modes of the sport – defence, on offence and at clearance.
I feel Taranto’s a complete star and he’s going to have a big impact on the Tigers; I feel he’s going to be thought of a top-five participant within the competitors on the finish of the 12 months.
Predicted end
Johnson: Finals
King: Top 4
Montagna: Finals
ST KILDA
LAST YEAR: tenth, 11-11, 99.3%
Montagna: To play finals this 12 months they most likely wanted all the things to go their means, and thus far it’s been something however, led by Max King.
What he’ll (Ross Lyon) do is, he’s there to determine which gamers are a part of the answer and can take this membership ahead to get the place they wish to get to, and which of them are a part of the issue? Which ones aren’t driving the requirements and performing week-in, week-out?
They’re someplace in that eight to 10-win mark, hopefully knocking on the door of the highest eight however they’re lacking some key personnel.
King: This was a full membership balls-up, let’s be sincere. They aimed to get again into the finals quite than get again to being in premiership competition.
Those drafts (and commerce intervals) of ‘18, ‘19 and ‘20, they fattened a list but not with guys who were going to take them to the promised land. Some of them are still there, some of them cost a lot of financial grief with their salary cap.
It’ll be a regression to then go ahead once more with a 12 months of intel of who these gamers are prone to be. I’ve received nice confidence in Ross, in Rob Harvey, in Corey Enright, Damian Carroll, Lenny Hayes, Brendon Goddard. You’re not gonna get a greater crew than that to teach these younger gamers who will not be as much as it for the primary 24 months, however they’re gonna get the very best schooling for all times after that.
Johnson: I hope he will get to a couple gamers, even to the likes of Jack Steele who’s a gun, and provides a layer to his sport.
I hope Jack’s not sitting there going I’m at a stage now; I need Ross to seize him and take him to a stage he didn’t even know existed in his soccer. That’s what we have to see from among the senior core gamers on this listing.
Montagna: And I feel that’s what the membership meant once they moved on (Brett) Ratten – there may be a lot upside in a few of these gamers, like Hunter Clark, Nick Coffield, even a Dan Butler. There’s nonetheless a lot scope in each single one in all them to enhance their soccer.
Predicted end
Johnson: Just miss finals
King: Bottom 4
Montagna: Just miss finals
SYDNEY SWANS
LAST YEAR: third and misplaced Grand Final, 16-6, 127.9%
Montagna: Sydney have to defy historical past, and that’s only a reality. The final 10 groups to lose a Grand Final by 40 factors or extra, six of them didn’t play finals the subsequent 12 months and the opposite 4 didn’t win a closing. Only three groups within the final 25 years have misplaced a Grand Final after which gained it the next 12 months, so it’s very uncommon to have the ability to bounce again.
They’ve received some historical past to defy however are they adequate? I feel so. Their model stacks up, they’re well-coached, we all know they’ve received stacks of expertise.
The solely query is did it come possibly somewhat bit too early? When you look again, Melbourne 2018 had been a younger aspect, they went over to Perth and received humiliated (within the preliminary closing) … West Coast 2015, Grand Final, received discovered towards the Hawks and three years later they bounce again and win it.
That’s my query with the Swans, little question they’re adequate however possibly it is perhaps a 12 months or two earlier than they get again up the summit.
Johnson: Physically they appear as sturdy as we’ve seen them, their operating energy’s precisely the place it ought to be heading into one other residence and away season, and so it lays with John Longmire and I feel he would’ve bought it in a extremely sturdy, optimistic means as a result of their season final 12 months was glorious.
King: They’re boys to males. They’re changing into males proper earlier than our very eyes; they’re nonetheless 14th within the competitors for age, so that they’re doing all of this forward of time. This is on absolute expertise and somewhat little bit of system. Eighth for expertise, so that they’ve pushed video games into these youngsters and received an unbelievable return.
It’s a brutal competitors … however most groups that lose a Grand Final are cherry ripe with age and once they tip over they tip proper over and also you nearly begin once more. This group is extremely younger. Third 12 months for (Errol) Gulden, (Braeden) Campbell, (Logan) McDonald, fourth 12 months for Chad Warner, fifth 12 months for (Nick) Blakey, (Justin) McInerney, (Sam) Wicks. They are simply studying how good they are often, these guys.
Montagna: You take into consideration Chad Warner final 12 months, his third 12 months within the competitors and elevated to a top-20 participant within the sport and Brownlow smoky. I can see the identical factor occurring with Errol Gulden, one other one they’ll add by way of the midfield as some extent of distinction to the (Luke) Parker, (James) Rowbottom, (Callum) Mills sorts.
Predicted end
Johnson: Top 4
King: Finals
Montagna: Finals (“should win a final, even a couple”)
WEST COAST EAGLES
LAST YEAR: seventeenth, 2-20, 59.8%
King: I feel Adam Simpson’s received the hardest job in soccer this 12 months. To get them again being aggressive, new strategies, there’s been a tinkering with the way in which they wish to play.
They’ve challenged their gamers to get fitter, they clearly haven’t been on the stage the final couple of years – whether or not that’s by way of harm or lack of want, which may occur once you’ve had a premiership. They had been impacted by Covid however that’s not an out for them final 12 months, they had been poor.
So their management group must regain their kind and their skill to truly lead. I have a look at (Elliot) Yeo he appears a distinct commodity, Nic Nat’s out for the time being, (Jeremy) McGovern appears actually match, the fittest I’ve seen him in years, (Andrew) Gaff’s again to full well being, (Tim) Kelly’s received to step up, (Dom) Sheed’s received to step up.
Montagna: They’re in no man’s land, as a result of they do have sufficient top-end expertise to most likely win 7 to 10 video games, notably at residence, however then the place does that go away them?
I don’t suppose they’ve received sufficient younger expertise to be seeing these inexperienced shoots and handing the keys over to that group, so that they’re nonetheless going to be counting on their 29-plus gamers, most of them premiership gamers and All-Australians, however they’re getting in direction of the ends of their careers.
Johnson: Bottom six draw, they’ll win their seven to 9 video games … final 12 months they packed up early understanding what they needed to realize this 12 months with health and getting their gamers again to AFL customary health, which they weren’t at off the again of a variety of operations the 12 months earlier than.
They recognized that and now with Oscar Allen coming again match as effectively provides layer to them.
Predicted end
Johnson: Just miss finals
King: Just miss finals
Montagna: Just miss finals
WESTERN BULLDOGS
LAST YEAR: eighth and misplaced elimination closing, 12-10, 108.9%
Johnson: Seeing Liam Jones in his first two (apply) video games and what he’s going to convey defensively, it’s crucial. Because they weren’t going to get there with (Ryan) Gardner and (Alex) Keath as the important thing two.
You throw Jones there as the important thing and the one who can cowl the contests with real energy and pace, it helps Gardner and Keath and (Josh) Bruce turns into the fourth who can move again there. And (Sam) Darcy’s the swingman at both finish; he’s not prepared bodily to go key again, and he’s not prepared bodily to play key ahead persistently over a complete sport but. That’s nonetheless a couple of years away.
Then you go (Aaron) Naughton, (Rory) Lobb and (Jamarra) Ugle-Hagan who’s just a bit bit additional in entrance in his growth as a participant, and (Tim) English, swiftly it’s the keys. We know what they’ve received within the midfield, I feel Anthony Scott will go to a different stage this 12 months, (Toby) McLean helps with some flexibility and what they’ll do at floor stage.
Montagna: Last 12 months most of their sport stacked up; with the footy, their clearance sport, their groundball sport. It was defensively they had been horrible.
But now Jones is the anchor of that defence, and other people have forgotten he was the No.1 intercept mark participant within the competitors – from 2018-2021 he’s averaged essentially the most intercept marks of any participant.
I feel even shedding (Josh) Dunkley and Lachie Hunter can generally be a optimistic; we’ve seen it with different golf equipment, all of us suppose shedding gamers is a nasty factor – Fremantle misplaced Adam Cerra and had been truly higher for it. I like the steadiness now with simply these 5 midfielders, with (Adam) Treloar, Bailey Smith after which Libba (Tom Liberatore), (Jack) Macrae, Bont (Marcus Bontempelli), these 5 can spend on a regular basis by way of the midfield. Sometimes you’re making an attempt to please all people taking part in blokes within the centre bounce and looking for spots for guys on ahead flanks.
I simply suppose they’re prepared now, I’m fairly bullish – they’ll win the flag this 12 months.
King: I don’t suppose you possibly can ever have too many good gamers. Josh Dunkley was their defensive midfielder, their No.1 tackler, the one which when the ball went the opposite means, he was the primary to react.
They don’t actually have that with the opposite guys you talked about, they’re going a method and that’s a secondary motion.
Predicted end
Johnson: Finals
King: Finals
Montagna: Top 4
Originally revealed as Two golf equipment predicted to battle for final supremacy in 2023 season
Source: www.news.com.au
